Drug possession is not a blanket charge, and can be broken down in a few different ways. Two of the categories drug charges can be placed into include actual possession, and constructive possession. What’s the difference, and could the classification affect your charges? Salt Lake City drug defense lawyer Darwin Overson explains.
You Can Be Charged with Criminal Possession… Even if There Are No Drugs on Your Person
You don’t actually need to have any drugs on your physical person in order to be charged with drug possession in the state of Utah. All that matters is that the prosecutor can prove that you had both the means and the intention to control drugs (or drug paraphernalia), such as keeping drugs nearby while waiting to make a sale. This concept is known as “constructive possession,” as opposed to a suspect allegedly having drugs on their person or in their bag or purse, which is known as “actual possession.”
Because constructive possession is more intangible and abstract in nature than actual physical possession, the courts must rely on a few different forms of evidence against the defendant. For example, the courts may consider factors such as whether or not you made any incriminating statements (which reinforces the idea that it’s best not to speak with police until you’ve consulted a Park City drug possession attorney), whether you have a record of drug crimes, how near you were physically located to the area in which the transaction(s) occurred, and whether you were acting suspiciously (such as casing an area or showing signs of drug intoxication, e.g. aggressive or erratic behavior).
State v. Cardona-Gueton: Proving a “Sufficient Nexus”
While suspicious behavior can be a major contributing factor, suspicious circumstances alone are not sufficient to prove that a defendant is truly guilty of constructive possession. As with other crimes, the prosecuting attorney must be able to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you, as the defendant, were exercising control over the narcotics in question. In the 2012 case of State v. Cardona-Gueton, the Utah Court of Appeals ruled the following:
“Constructive possession must be proven by a sufficient nexus between the defendant and the drugs to permit a factual inference that the defendant had the power and the intent to exercise control over the drugs.”
In that case, the sequence of events was that:
- Rolando Cardona-Gueton was apprehended by police officers who suspected he had been selling heroin, cocaine, and meth.
- As the officers approached Cardona-Gueton, he was drinking from a water bottle which had been attached to a bicycle situated next to Cardona-Gueton.
- The police asked Cardona-Gueton if the bicycle was his, which he confirmed.
- The police then searched over the bicycle, and found drugs hidden inside.
- Cardona-Gueton had an amount of money which matched what he would have earned from the suspected sales.
Cardona-Gueton did not have drugs on his person, but the link between his ownership of the money, the bicycle, and the presence of the contraband inside, combined with the fact that he had been witnessed behaving suspiciously by the police, ultimately added up to prove constructive possession. This would be the “sufficient nexus.”
Possible Defenses Against Constructive Possession Charges in Utah
As intent is also a key factor in proving guilt, it must also be established that you planned to “exercise control” over the contraband in question. If were not in a position where you could have exercised control — perhaps because you weren’t even present when the drugs were left in a certain room or vehicle, or because you can’t identify a substance and didn’t even know what it was, or perhaps because you’re a single employee at a vast business with hundreds of people filtering in and out of the building — that may be able to help bolster your defense. In this way, the complexity of proving constructive possession can sometimes work in the defendant’s favor.
In terms of the potential penalties, it doesn’t make much difference whether you are convicted of actual or constructive possession. In either case, you would be facing the same amount of jail time and restitution. Factors which can make sentencing worse, which are known as aggravating factors, include selling drugs in a school zone, committing child endangerment, weapons possession, or having a history of prior offenses. As the quantity of drug increases, the penalties become harsher, and a misdemeanor could even become a felony.
If you’ve been charged with constructive or actual possession in Utah, you need an aggressive Salt Lake City criminal defense lawyer on your side. To set up a free and private case evaluation, call attorney Darwin Overson at (801) 758-2287 today.
Get Your FREE Consultation
"Tawni was the best attorney I could have asked to represent me!"
Tawni was the best attorney I could have asked to represent me! Truly the most kind and empathetic person and it’s no surprise that she is so great at what she does! She represented me like she had known me for years and I couldn’t have asked for someone more understanding of my situation. Look no further, she’s the right choice!!
Google Review
"Tawni was fantastic to work with."
Tawni was fantastic to work with. She was quick to respond, professional, and got the job done. I have worked with others in the past and I am grateful Tawni was available and able to help me when I needed it most.
Google Review
"I highly recommend Tawni Bugden to anyone in need of reliable and effective legal representation."
I had the pleasure of working with Tawni Bugden for my sons recent case, and I am beyond impressed with the level of dedication, expertise, and professionalism she provided. From the very beginning, Tawni Bugden took the time to thoroughly understand the details of my sons case, offering clear and straightforward advice. She was always responsive to my questions and kept me informed throughout my son's entire process. What really stood out to me was her ability to break down complex legal concepts into simple terms, making it easy for me to make informed decisions. Tawni's attention to detail, combined with their strategic approach, led to a successful outcome that exceeded my expectations.
I highly recommend Tawni Bugden to anyone in need of reliable and effective legal representation. She will truly go above and beyond for her clients, and I am grateful for everything she did to help my son achieve a positive result!
Google Review
"I wish him a happy life in and out of work."
Darwin Overson went above and beyond and proved my innocence in trial at a time that I felt all was lost and was an excellent listener. Well worth the money spent. He even helped provide documentation for things after the case was over when I was in a pinch (great client service). I wish him a happy life in and out of work.
Google Review
"He is worth every Dollar!"
Darwin, exceeded my expectations, I was suspected of serious charges and he did everything in his power to give me an excellent criminal defense, I recommend him without any doubt, his prices are fair he is worth every Dollar! Thanks to Mr. Overson I'm a Free Man🙏🏼
Google Review
"When you retain this team you are already on the way to making your situation better."
When you are going through all of the stress of what an arrest can bring, The uncertainty alone can destroy you. Darwin and his team did more the Defend. They provided Hope and took away the feeling of being alone. Even after the trial they continued to monitor our case through probation. When you retain this team you are already on the way to making your situation better.
Google Review
"Tawni Bugden, Esq. is an exceedingly dedicated, highly skilled, and articulate criminal defense attorney."
My wife and I reside in the Northeast. We retained Tawni Bugden, Esq. to defend a family member who was receiving mental health treatment in Salt Lake City. We were immediately impressed with Tawni’s broad experience as a defense attorney. The fact that she had previously and successfully defended mentally ill and neurodiverse individuals made her the perfect fit for our circumstances. Tawni is extremely well versed in Utah state and local criminal law. She has worked extensively with state and local law enforcement and prosecution. To say that Tawni was our “eyes and ears” on the ground is an understatement! She provided excellent counsel, timely updates and promptly returned our phone calls, of which there were many given our geographic location. Her responsiveness even extended into her European vacation! Tawni Bugden, Esq. is an exceedingly dedicated, highly skilled, and articulate criminal defense attorney. We are forever grateful for her guidance and support.
Google Review
"Forever grateful and highly recommend him."
I had the opportunity to see Mr. Overson in action during trial. He is professional, confident, knowledgeable, has a great strategy, communication style, and empathy. I could tell he prepared extensively for the case and did not hold back to defend his client, which resulted in success. Forever grateful and highly recommend him.
Google Review
"I am blessed to have had her experience and exceptional level of help."
When I was in trouble, and I needed help, i didn't know what to do. Tawni Budgen was who helped me through it. I am blessed to have had her experience and exceptional level of help.
Google Review
"This Lawyer, Tawni Bugden, is truly a rare gem."
This Lawyer, Tawni Bugden is truly a rare gem. Tawni goes above and beyond for her clients. Tawni is very prompt on calling you back the same day you send her a message, no matter what time her day ended. I would recommend this attorney to my family and friends.
Google Review
"Let me be the first to tell you, it’s worth every penny!"
Tawni is the best lawyer you could ask for She is very experienced and is extremely resourceful. If you’re hesitant for any reason on whether to choose her to represent you, let me be the first to tell you, it’s worth every penny!
Google Review
"Thank you so much, Tawni. You are truly a lifesaver."
Tawni is amazing. We were very scared and overwhelmed For our son’s future, And she gave us hope. Telling us to stay positive and be patient. That helped a lot. Going Through things you’ve never gone through Before and not knowing how to handle things, Tawni gives a lot of feedback and is always communicating to make any transition dealing with the legal system easier. She fights hard and ends disputes quickly. Winning this case and being able to tell our son, he’s free, was seriously the best feeling. Thank you so much, Tawni. You are truly a lifesaver.
Google Review
"Tawni made what could have been a stressful experience seamless and provided me with peace of mind."
I had the pleasure of working with Tawni Bugden to expunge two non-convictions, and I couldn't be happier with the results. Tawni is simply amazing and incredibly talented. Her expertise in the legal field is unmatched, and her dedication to her clients is commendable. She navigated the process with finesse and ensured that my rights were protected every step of the way. Tawni made what could have been a stressful experience seamless and provided me with peace of mind. I highly recommend her services to anyone in need of exceptional legal representation.
Google Review
"For unparalleled legal representation, Overson & Bugden PLLC is the unequivocal choice."
Overson & Bugden PLLC exemplifies legal excellence. With profound expertise and unwavering dedication, they adeptly navigate complex legal issues. Their commitment to client satisfaction is unmatched, ensuring clear communication and attentive support throughout. Professionalism permeates every interaction, from their knowledgeable attorneys to their meticulous attention to detail. For unparalleled legal representation, Overson & Bugden PLLC is the unequivocal choice.
Google Review
"Having Tawni representing just made everything feel and be more smooth."
We are beyond grateful to have been able to work with attorney Tawni Bugden. Since the first time we spoke over the phone she gave me hope, sense of relief and free judgment!! She always was available to my questions and concerns even at times she had to explain to me more than once. Having a family member in jail and going through the whole process of courts and wanting to do more for them it’s the worst feeling ever, but having Tawni representing just made everything feel and be more smooth and had such a amazing outcome. She was able to get no prison time and even be released before sentencing court. Honestly if I was ever to go through this situation again ( hope I never do) no doubt Tawni will be our attorney!!! They are the Best!!! They know what they are doing and most importantly they don’t give any false hopes and the results they can get.
Google Review
"I cannot express enough how much Tawni Bugden has changed the direction of my life (and my children's) for the better!"
I cannot express enough how much Tawni Bugden has changed the direction of my life (and my children's) for the better! She was able to get the best possible outcome for me as my legal representation in my criminal matter and I will forever be thankful for all her support! She is a formidable force in the courtroom and she knows her stuff! Thank you Tawni Bugden!
Google Review
“If someone is making allegations against you, you really should talk to Darwin.”
I was charged with domestic violence and the allegations were that I abused my husband. Truth is, my husband was abusive to me. I hired Darwin and we had a trial. During the trial, Darwin was able to show the jury that it was my husband that was abusive and was trying to manipulate the process of our divorce. The jury found me not guilty and after the trial one of the jurors approached me and told me how impressed the jury was with the way Darwin presented the defense. Before the trial, my now soon to be ex-husband tried to convince me to plead guilty. So going to trial was really the first time I was able to stand up to him and not let him manipulate my life anymore. Darwin really helped me with that process and I can’t express how empowering it has been. If someone is making allegations against you, you really should talk to Darwin.
Google Review
“If you or a loved one is in trouble, Darwin is your guy.”
“I was arrested for DUI. From the very beginning Darwin was very professional and supportive. Throughout the court process I was scared. I kept telling Darwin that wanted to plead guilty just to end it but Darwin encouraged me to stick with it and take the case to trial. The morning of trial, Darwin was able to cross examine the (arresting) officer in such a way as to show the jury that there was reasonable doubt as to the accuracy of the breathalyzer machine. That was important because they were saying my BAC was .182. Darwin walked me through my testimony so that the jury understood what happened from my point of view. I think if he hadn’t been able to help me through my testimony the way he did that the jury wouldn’t have understood and they would have convicted me. The jury deliberated for two hours and then returned a verdict of not guilty.I am really thankful that Darwin was my attorney and that I took his advice to take my case to a jury. If you or a loved one is in trouble, Darwin is your guy.”
Google Review
“The jury found my husband not guilty and I credit Darwin for making that happen.”
“My husband was charged with a first degree felony sex crime against our granddaughter. Anyone who knew my husband knew he didn’t do it. He was the type to protect children not hurt them. We had been represented by another attorney who just couldn’t get the prosecutor to see that the charges weren’t good. When it came time for trial, that attorney was scared to try the case. We were referred to Darwin and I am so grateful. Trial was a week long and by the end, Darwin had shown the jury how our grandchild had been manipulated by the social workers and her mother to say things that were not true. Darwin was careful and thorough in his investigation and preparation before trial and it really showed in court. The jury found my husband not guilty and I credit Darwin for making that happen.”
Google Review
“I thank Darwin …had it not been for him, things would have turned out very differently for me and not in a good way.”
“Several years ago, I was having troubles in my marriage. There were lots of arguments and it was clear that we were headed for a separation. One night I was woke up by six West Valley Police officers standing around my bed with flashlights shining in my eyes. It was 3:00 in the morning and they drug me to the police station where they informed me that I was being arrested for engaging in sexual relations with my baby girl. I could not believe it. Over the next several days I lost my job because of these allegations and a protective order issued against me preventing me from seeing my wife and child, and even from going to the house to get my things. My world was turned upside down. I hired Darwin to represent me. He helped me get my job back, over turned the protective order and through his own investigation was able to uncover enough about my wife to convince the prosecutor to drop all charges against me. About six months later my wife was arrested for possessing thousands of dollars of fake checks. I have moved on and remarried. I thank Darwin for helping me through an incredibly difficult part of my life and I think had it not been for him, things would have turned out very differently for me and not in a good way.”
Google Review
Related Posts
